What Mark Manson Teaches About Choosing What to Care About

We often chase an idea of constant happiness, bombarded with messages urging us to think positive, visualize success, and strive for more. But what if this relentless pursuit is actually counterproductive? What if the secret to a more fulfilling life lies not in adding more, but in carefully choosing what truly deserves our attention and energy? This is about learning the subtle art of focusing on what genuinely matters, a perspective powerfully articulated by Mark Manson in his book, The Subtle Art of Not Giving a F*ck.

The Downside of Non-Stop Positivity

Manson points out that the modern push for constant positivity can paradoxically highlight what we lack. Trying hard to feel rich reminds us of our financial anxieties; forcing affirmations of beauty underscores feelings of inadequacy; visualizing success emphasizes its current absence. This cycle is often fueled by societal pressures suggesting happiness comes from acquiring more – more possessions, more achievements, a better image. Life can become a frantic race towards an elusive mirage of happiness, where pleasure is tied to the superficial and temporary. While this benefits commerce, Manson argues it often breeds personal anxiety. Perhaps the key isn't accumulating more worries, but cultivating fewer, focusing only on what is genuinely important.

When things don't go our way, or we feel inadequate compared to the seemingly perfect lives displayed on social media, a spiral of anxiety can begin. We worry about our situation, then worry about worrying. To break free, Manson suggests we might need to consciously filter out externally imposed values and false aspirations. True growth often comes through navigating negative experiences – the pain in the gym builds strength, business mistakes forge resilience, facing fears cultivates courage. Interestingly, the less desperately we crave something, the more attainable it might become – a concept Manson explores related to the "law of reverse effort." Success sometimes finds those who weren't obsessively chasing it.

Learning to Prioritize Your Concerns

Mastering this art of selective focus, as described by Manson, involves a few key principles:

  • Firstly, it's not about total indifference. A person who selectively focuses still cares deeply about their goals and values, remaining unfazed by unavoidable obstacles or the opinions of others regarding actions they deem right and worthy. They don't ignore everything, just the secondary noise.
  • Secondly, to stop sweating the small stuff, we need a clear sense of what's truly significant. People overwhelmed by minor annoyances – a social media post, battery life, a minor inconvenience – often lack deeper, more meaningful concerns to occupy their minds. The real issue isn't the triviality itself, but the absence of substantial anchors in life.
  • Thirdly, we often shape our own anxieties by deciding what matters. Reflecting on past worries often reveals they had little long-term impact. With age and experience, we naturally become more selective about where we invest our emotional energy.

Happiness Resides in Solving Problems

Manson emphasizes that life inherently involves challenges; it's a form of suffering, experienced differently by everyone. The wealthy face issues related to wealth, the poor due to poverty; loneliness brings its own pain, while family life presents different struggles. The idea that happiness is a final state achieved through specific accomplishments ("If I get X, I'll be happy") is often misleading. As the book suggests, happiness isn't an equation to solve.

In fact, feelings of dissatisfaction and unease are crucial drivers of change, innovation, and survival. We are often wired to feel discontent with what we have and yearn for what we lack. A life without problems isn't realistic; problems simply change form. The goal isn't to eliminate problems, but, as Manson advocates, to engage with better, more meaningful ones – problems worth the effort and struggle. Happiness often emerges from the process of solving these worthwhile problems.

Consider improving physical fitness: signing up for a gym solves one issue but introduces new challenges – finding time, enduring workouts, managing logistics. This pattern repeats everywhere. Many desire outcomes like love, career success, or financial freedom, but fewer ask what struggles, sacrifices, or pain they are willing to endure to achieve them. Are you ready for the long hours, the difficult decisions, the persistent effort? The struggle itself, the path chosen, often defines success and happiness more than the final reward. Pain and suffering also serve as vital feedback, teaching us boundaries and helping us avoid future mistakes, much like how a child learns about the physical world.

The Freedom of Being Ordinary

Manson challenges the cultural emphasis on high self-esteem that promoted the idea that everyone is inherently exceptional. He argues this often led to disappointment when innate talent didn't magically manifest without effort. Reality shows that genuine achievement stems from consistent effort, determination, and the hard-won ability to prioritize. Embracing the idea that you might be quite ordinary, not uniquely blessed nor uniquely cursed, can be incredibly liberating.

There's no need for special treatment, either because you think you're wonderful or because you believe you're uniquely flawed. Shifting blame or constantly viewing oneself as a victim is as draining as baseless self-aggrandizement. Believing your problems are insurmountable requires as much energy as denying they exist. Letting go of the pressure to be extraordinary frees up immense mental space. Stress diminishes, and energy becomes available for pursuing what you genuinely want, without crippling fear or inflated expectations.

Unpacking the Value of Suffering

To ensure suffering isn't in vain, Manson suggests it helps to understand its roots. This involves peeling back layers, like an onion: first, recognizing your emotions; second, questioning why you feel them; and third, identifying the personal values underlying these feelings. Why do you label something a success or failure? Our chosen values determine the nature of our problems, which in turn shapes our life quality.

If our values are flawed – like an endless pursuit of more money without asking why – everything built upon them becomes shaky. Will relentless work or material accumulation truly bring lasting happiness? Often, the joy derived from purchases diminishes over time. Similarly, a constant need to be right prevents learning from mistakes, while insisting on positivity denies the existence of problems, thereby robbing us of the chance to solve them and find meaning. Avoiding problems can lead to a life devoid of significance. Manson uses examples like Dave Mustaine to illustrate how someone can achieve massive success but still feel like a failure because they measure themselves against an irrelevant standard – their chosen value prevents them from recognizing their actual accomplishments.

The Defining Power of Choice and Responsibility

Our lives are shaped by moments of choice. Choosing a difficult path willingly, like running a marathon for personal achievement, feels vastly different from being forced into hardship. As Manson highlights, the key difference often lies in whether we chose the struggle and take responsibility for it.

Even in situations largely outside our control, we retain the power to choose our response and interpretation. Refusing to react is still a reaction. Accepting responsibility for our perspective and reaction, rather than blaming external factors or people, is empowering. The same event can be viewed as good or bad depending on our chosen lens. Taking ownership of our problems is the first step towards solving them and fostering personal growth. While blaming others might offer temporary relief, it leaves the underlying issues unresolved. Someone convinced their perceived flaw dictates their fate has chosen a limiting value, overlooking possibilities and confirming their own negative beliefs. Life deals different hands, but our decisions shape the outcome.

Growth Through Accepting You Might Be Wrong

Looking back, we can often see how our views and beliefs have changed. What seemed certain in the past may appear misguided now. This pattern will likely continue; our future selves will probably find flaws in our current perspectives. This isn't failure; as Manson puts it, it's growth. Moving from wrong to less wrong is progress.

True change requires the humility to admit we might be mistaken. Before setting life priorities, it's crucial to question our current values. We often resist information or opportunities that threaten our self-image or deeply held beliefs, even if they could improve our lives. Fear keeps us in familiar, albeit limiting, roles. We miss chances because they challenge the stories we tell ourselves about who we are. Letting go of these fixed narratives frees us to act, experiment, and grow through potential failure. Regularly asking, "What if I'm wrong?" can illuminate errors in thinking. Considering what that wrongness might mean helps draw accurate conclusions. And assessing whether admitting wrongness creates more problems or fewer helps navigate complex situations.

Viewing Defeat as Forward Motion

Success often correlates with the number of failures experienced. Someone better skilled has likely failed more often. Manson uses the analogy of a toddler learning to walk: they fall constantly but don't conclude walking isn't for them. The fear of failure is often learned.

This fear makes us cling to the safe and familiar. But true success often requires the willingness to fail. When action itself becomes the measure of success, failure loses its sting, and any result provides useful feedback. Inspiration becomes a reward for action, not a prerequisite. Manson advocates the "Do Something" principle: if you lack motivation for an important change, just do something – anything related. Action often generates emotional response and inspiration, creating momentum for further action. Forcing oneself to take even a small step can ignite the process.

The Strength in Saying "No"

The inability to say "no" often stems from a desire to be liked, avoid conflict, or maintain constant positivity. People pleasers prioritize immediate comfort – their own and others' – avoiding potential discomfort or disappointment. However, this avoidance comes at a cost.

Refusal is a crucial life skill, Manson asserts. Saying "yes" indiscriminately means we lack priorities. We end up bogged down in commitments or relationships that drain us. Saying "no" to opportunities, activities, or even relationships that aren't right for us frees up space for what truly matters. Rejecting alternatives clarifies our values and deepens our commitment to what we choose. Loyalty to a place, a belief, or a person gains meaning through the alternatives declined. More isn't always better; happiness often lies in having less but better. Overload leads to the "paradox of choice," where too many options make us less satisfied with our final decision. Choosing one value means rejecting others. These are healthy boundaries built on refusal.

Living Fully in the Face of the End

Manson concludes by exploring how accepting our own mortality can profoundly clarify our values. The awareness that time is limited strips away superficial concerns and false priorities. It makes it easier to take responsibility, face fears, endure setbacks, and embrace necessary refusals. Thoughts of the end cut through the trivial pursuits – the extra dollar, the fleeting praise, the need to always be right.

It forces a crucial question: What legacy will you leave? Confronting this is uncomfortable but necessary, Manson argues, to prevent empty values from dominating our lives. We are already significant, not because of external achievements, but because we engage in the constant process of choosing what matters to us and what doesn't. This very act of choosing our values, moment by moment, is what makes a life meaningful and authentically successful, whether we fully realize it or not.

Reference:

  • Manson, Mark (2016). The Subtle Art of Not Giving a F*ck: A Counterintuitive Approach to Living a Good Life. HarperOne.

    This book serves as the primary source for the counter-intuitive ideas explored throughout this article. Manson challenges conventional self-help notions and advocates for choosing meaningful values, embracing negative experiences and limitations, taking responsibility for one's choices and reactions, and prioritizing focus to live a more contented, grounded life.

You need to be logged in to send messages
Login Sign up
To create your specialist profile, please log in to your account.
Login Sign up
You need to be logged in to contact us
Login Sign up
To create a new Question, please log in or create an account
Login Sign up
Share on other sites

If you are considering psychotherapy but do not know where to start, a free initial consultation is the perfect first step. It will allow you to explore your options, ask questions, and feel more confident about taking the first step towards your well-being.

It is a 30-minute, completely free meeting with a Mental Health specialist that does not obligate you to anything.

What are the benefits of a free consultation?

Who is a free consultation suitable for?

Important:

Potential benefits of a free initial consultation

During this first session: potential clients have the chance to learn more about you and your approach before agreeing to work together.

Offering a free consultation will help you build trust with the client. It shows them that you want to give them a chance to make sure you are the right person to help them before they move forward. Additionally, you should also be confident that you can support your clients and that the client has problems that you can help them cope with. Also, you can avoid any ethical difficult situations about charging a client for a session in which you choose not to proceed based on fit.

We've found that people are more likely to proceed with therapy after a free consultation, as it lowers the barrier to starting the process. Many people starting therapy are apprehensive about the unknown, even if they've had sessions before. Our culture associates a "risk-free" mindset with free offers, helping people feel more comfortable during the initial conversation with a specialist.

Another key advantage for Specialist

Specialists offering free initial consultations will be featured prominently in our upcoming advertising campaign, giving you greater visibility.

It's important to note that the initial consultation differs from a typical therapy session:

No Internet Connection It seems you’ve lost your internet connection. Please refresh your page to try again. Your message has been sent