Someone once told me that if you could eliminate two traits from people—greed and jealousy—their psychological well-being would significantly improve. At first, this seemed like a hopeful, if idealistic, vision. But it led me to a deeper question: Can these traits truly be removed? Are they ingrained in us biologically, or are they products of culture and experience? To explore this, I turned to Jesse J. Prinz's groundbreaking book, Beyond Human Nature: How Culture and Experience Shape the Human Mind.

The Nature vs. Nurture Debate Revisited

Prinz opens his book by revisiting the classic nature vs. nurture debate, challenging the prevailing belief that our psychological traits are largely hardwired by biology. He argues that human beings are not born with fixed traits, but rather develop them through a dynamic interplay of culture, history, and experience (Prinz, 2012).

In essence, while biology provides the potential, it is culture that activates and shapes behavior. This becomes crucial when we examine traits like greed and jealousy, often assumed to be immutable parts of "human nature."

Greed and Jealousy: Natural or Nurtured?

Prinz would likely argue that greed and jealousy are not universal or inevitable, but culturally conditioned. These emotions serve functions within specific societies. For example, in individualistic cultures that prioritize personal success and material wealth, greed may be incentivized. Similarly, jealousy can be intensified in environments where competition and comparison are norms (Prinz, Chapter 11).

Research highlighted by Prinz shows that emotions and moral values vary widely across cultures. In Micronesia, for instance, different emotional responses to social status challenge the assumption that all humans experience envy or jealousy in the same way (Prinz, Chapter 10). These findings suggest that what we often call "human nature" may in fact be human culture.

Can These Traits Be Unlearned?

If greed and jealousy are cultural products, they can potentially be unlearned or reshaped. This idea is consistent with Prinz's broader thesis: human behavior is incredibly plastic. The mind is not a fixed entity but a flexible system that responds to upbringing, environment, and social norms (Prinz, Preface).

To eliminate or reduce these traits, we would need systemic cultural shifts. Educational systems, media narratives, and community practices would all have to reinforce values like empathy, cooperation, and sufficiency over competition and accumulation.

Why This Matters

Prinz's work is a compelling reminder that human psychology is not destiny. Traits we assume are natural may be learned, and what is learned can be changed. As he writes, "Describing human behavior as a conspiracy of nature and nurture is true but terribly misleading."—we must ask, which one holds the steering wheel? (Prinz, Chapter 1).

So, can we remove greed and jealousy? Not by altering genes, but by transforming culture. This is no small task, but it's a hopeful one. If human nature is shaped by experience, then better experiences can shape better people.

_________________________________________________________________________________________

References:

• Prinz, J. J. (2012). Beyond Human Nature: How Culture and Experience Shape the Human Mind. W. W. Norton & Company.